top of page

Winning the Bid: Navigating Multiple Offers in the Real Estate Game

In the dynamic world of real estate, particularly in a bustling market like California, the concept of multiple offers can significantly influence the buying and selling process. Multiple offers occur when more than one prospective buyer submits an offer on a property within a relatively short timeframe. This scenario often leads to a competitive bidding situation and sellers usually come out on top. Understanding how multiple offers work is crucial for both buyers and sellers navigating the California real estate market.

The Dynamics of Multiple Offers:

1. Seller's Market Influence:

With buyers coming back to the market and the challenge of continued low inventory, multiple offers will be part of the spring and summer selling market on the Monterey Peninsula and across California. Buyers will need to make compelling offers to secure their desired properties. Sellers, in turn, will leverage this competition to negotiate better terms, including higher sale prices and favorable contingencies.

2. Buyer Strategies:

Buyers facing a multiple offer situation must strategize to increase their chances of success. This may involve submitting strong initial offers, including competitive prices, favorable terms, proof of financing and quick response times. Their goal is to stand out among competing offers.

3. Seller Considerations:

For sellers, multiple offers present an opportunity to maximize their returns. They can carefully review each offer, considering not only the offered price but also the terms and conditions outlined. Sellers may prioritize offers with fewer contingencies, shorter escrow periods, and evidence of financial stability. Ultimately, sellers have the discretion to accept, reject, or counter any offer they receive.

Handling Multiple Offers:

1. Presentation of Offers:

A Seller may set an offer review date so they have the opportunity to gather as many offers as possible. Once the review date is at hand, the listing agent is required to present all offers to the seller. Side by side comparisons should be done so the seller can make an informed decision.

2. Counter Offers

Sellers may choose to counter one or more offers to negotiate more favorable terms. Counteroffers typically involve proposing adjustments to the purchase price, closing timeline, or contingencies that were outlined in the original offer. The seller would issue 1) a multiple counter to 2 or more buyers if they want to encourage competition 2) accept an offer that met all of their needs 3) reject all other offers 4) ask for everyone’s “highest and best” offer. Buyers receiving a counteroffer can either accept, reject, or submit a Buyer’s counteroffer. A listing agent may have permission from the seller to tell each buyer’s agent where their offers need to be or buyers have to make a calculated guess on where the best offer will land. Multiple responses may occur until both parties reach mutual agreement or decide to move on.

3. Backup Offers:

Once the seller accepts a primary offer, they may offer a buyer a backup position. Backup offers serve as a safety net in case the primary deal falls through due to financing issues, inspection concerns, or other unforeseen circumstances. Buyers submitting backup offers should be prepared to move forward quickly if the primary deal collapses. The Backup offer will contain terms that clarify how the offer will proceed if the first offer falls through.

Most buyers don’t like the idea of a “bidding war” but in the current real estate environment, if they really want the property, they will have to jump into the game. Buyers can prepare themselves by establishing their financial limits ahead of time, clearly determining how badly they want the property, and sticking to their financial limits so they don’t make an impetuous decision they may regret. With the guidance of knowledgeable real estate professionals, navigating multiple offers can lead to successful transactions and satisfying outcomes for most parties involved. Don’t be afraid but be prepared!



bottom of page